Dec 13, 2018

How today's liability laws cover AV accidents

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

Autonomous vehicles are widely expected to reduce traffic fatalities, though the number of lives they could save is debated. When accidents do happen, however, self-driving cars aren't likely to present liability issues that current laws can't handle.

The big picture: The legal system already considers semi-autonomous vehicle technologies like anti-lock brakes, adaptive cruise control and electronic stability control. Although AVs may shift more liability risk to manufacturers, current laws around negligence and product liability should suffice for further increases in vehicle automation.

Details: There are four main causes of crashes, which the U.S. legal system will continue looking to when assigning liability for a crash involving an AV.

  1. Driver error. For the occupant of an AV, the equivalents of speeding or running a red light could be failing to monitor the vehicle as required or improperly manipulating or overriding its autonomous system. New legal questions may also arise around passengers — establishing whether they are responsible for any crashes, but also, when there are multiple people in an AV, where responsibility falls to all passengers or just one in the traditional driver's seat. At least initially, passengers will likely be judged against the existing “reasonable person” standard of negligence law.
  2. Design or manufacturing defects. Accidents due to vehicle assembly, software programming errors, sensor malfunctions or vehicle-to-vehicle communication failures would all be addressed by existing product lability laws. A programming error, for example, may cause a rear-end collision by unnecessarily engaging the vehicle’s brakes. If such an error causes a crash in conditions like bad weather, a manufacturer may consider the passenger partially at fault for failure to safely monitor or operate the vehicle.
  3. Poor maintenance. These issues — brakes wearing out, tires going bald — remain the responsibility of whoever owns or manages the vehicle.
  4. Unpredictable events. Accidents with unforeseeable causes, like a rock slide or deer running into the road, will be covered by liability laws as they have been. If no one is at fault, insurance can provide compensation for those injured.

Yes, but: Software programs that determine how an AV reacts when confronted with only undesirable outcomes will present challenging legal questions. Current law isn't equipped to address moral determinations — like whether to make a dangerous swerve, putting occupants at risk, when a pedestrian darts into the road and the vehicle can’t stop in time.

The bottom line: In the short term, AV litigation may take longer and cost more because judges and juries will need to learn about the technology, but it isn't likely to require major changes to current liability laws.

Michael Mallow is a partner and Rachel Straus is an associate with Sidley Austin LLP’s Consumer Class Action Defense practice.

This article has been prepared for informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice or reflect the views of Sidley Austin LLP.

Go deeper

U.S. coronavirus updates: Death toll nears 11,000

Data: The Center for Systems Science and Engineering at Johns Hopkins; Map: Andrew Witherspoon/Axios

Recorded deaths from the novel coronavirus surpassed 10,900 in the U.S. early Tuesday, per Johns Hopkins data. More than 1,000 people in the U.S. have died of coronavirus-related conditions each day since April 1.

Why it matters: U.S. Surgeon General Jerome Adams said on Sunday this week will be "the hardest and saddest week of most Americans' lives" — calling it our "our Pearl Harbor, our 9/11 moment."

Go deeperArrowUpdated 36 mins ago - Health

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 11:30 p.m. ET: 1,347,803 — Total deaths: 74,807 — Total recoveries: 277,402Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 11:30 p.m. ET: 368,196 — Total deaths: 10,986 — Total recoveries: 19,828Map.
  3. Trump administration latest: President Trump's economic adviser Peter Navarro warned White House colleagues in late January the coronavirus could take over half a million American lives and cost close to $6 trillion, memos obtained by Axios show.
  4. 2020 update: Wisconsin Supreme Court blocks governor's attempt to delay in-person primary voting delayed until June.
  5. States latest: West Coast states send ventilators to New York and other states with more immediate need — Data suggest coronavirus curve may be flattening in New York, Gov. Andrew Cuomo said.
  6. World update: U.K. Prime Minister Boris Johnson moved to intensive care as coronavirus symptoms worsen.
  7. Stocks latest: The S&P 500 closed up 7% on Monday, while the Dow rose more than 1,500 points.
  8. What should I do? Pets, moving and personal health. Answers about the virus from Axios expertsWhat to know about social distancingQ&A: Minimizing your coronavirus risk.
  9. Other resources: CDC on how to avoid the virus, what to do if you get it.

Subscribe to Mike Allen's Axios AM to follow our coronavirus coverage each morning from your inbox.

Docs: Navarro memos warning mass death circulated West Wing in January

Image from a memo to President Trump

In late January, President Trump's economic adviser Peter Navarro warned his White House colleagues the novel coronavirus could take more than half a million American lives and cost close to $6 trillion, according to memos obtained by Axios.

  • By late February, Navarro was even more alarmed, and he warned his colleagues, in another memo, that up to two million Americans could die of the virus.

Driving the news: Navarro's grim estimates are set out in two memos — one dated Jan. 29 and addressed to the National Security Council, the other dated Feb. 23 and addressed to the president. The NSC circulated both memos around the White House and multiple agencies.

Go deeperArrow2 hours ago - Health