Sep 7, 2017

How to evaluate breakthrough therapies

From our Expert Voices conversation on drug pricing.

The value of breakthrough therapies, such as Kymriah, the first approved Chimeric Antigen Receptor Therapy (CAR-T) should be evaluated with the following filters:

  1. Are these therapies providing incremental and meaningful benefit versus the available 'standard of care' and with a risk profile that is manageable for most of the patient population it will be used in? The evidence overwhelmingly indicates this is the case for Kymriah being used to treat children with leukemia.
  2. What is the current cost of alternative therapies for these patients, if they exist? For children with leukemia, their only other hope of a 'curative' treatment is a bone marrow transplant. The average cost of that and associated care is between $800,000 and $1 million, and reported success rates are lower than the new offering of CAR-T, which is only administered once to the patient in a 'transplant light' environment.
  3. What does it cost to make these therapies and deliver them to a patient? For most manufacturers of these therapies the initial 'cost of goods' will be high, much more than traditional medicines. As manufacturing science of these therapies improves, these costs will go down.

The bottom line: New therapies may cost comparatively less than existing ones — and deliver more.

Other voices in the conversation:

Go deeper

Biden formally secures Democratic presidential nomination

Joe Biden speaks at Delaware State University's student cente on June 5. Photo: Jim Watson/AFP via Getty Images

Former Vice President Joe Biden became the formal Democratic presidential nominee on Friday evening, per AP.

The big picture: Biden has been the presumptive frontrunner to take on President Trump since Sen. Bernie Sanders suspended his campaign in early April.

Updated 6 hours ago - Politics & Policy

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 9 p.m. ET: 6,724.516 — Total deaths: 394,018 — Total recoveries — 2,996,832Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 9 p.m. ET: 1,894,753 — Total deaths: 109,042 — Total recoveries: 491,706 — Total tested: 19,231,444Map.
  3. Public health: WHCA president says White House violated social-distancing guidelines to make reporters "a prop" — Jailing practices contribute to spread.
  4. Sports: How coronavirus could reshuffle the sports calendar.
  5. Jobs: Better-than-expected jobs report boosts stock market.
  6. Media: The Athletic lays off 8% of staff, implements company-wide pay cut.

Scoop: German foreign minister to travel to Israel with warning on annexation

Heiko Maas. Photo: Michael Kappeler/picture alliance via Getty Images

German Foreign Minister Heiko Maas is expected to travel to Israel next week to warn that there will be consequences if Israeli leaders move forward with plans to annex parts of the West Bank, Israeli officials and European diplomats tell me.

Why it matters: Israeli and European officials agree that if Israel goes ahead with unilateral annexation, the EU will respond with sanctions.