Sep 12, 2017

Experts say new, cheaper set of ACA plans wouldn't change much

Lamar Alexander wants to expand access to bare-bones insurance policies. (AP Photo/Alex Brandon, File)

Senate HELP Committee Chairman Lamar Alexander has made it clear that he's interested in letting people older than 30 buy "copper," or catastrophic, insurance plans through the Affordable Care Act's exchanges. He's talked about expanding access to those policies as part of a bill to stabilize the ACA's marketplaces. So, how exactly would this work?

  • A catastrophic plan — which is already available to people younger than 30 — is a policy whose deductible is equal to the law's cap on out-of-pocket spending.
  • The catch, as Larry Levitt of the Kaiser Family Foundation points out, is that a catastrophic plan is "pretty much indistinguishable from a bronze plan" in terms of how much of an enrollee's health care costs it covers.
  • To resolve this, the law's out-of-pocket maximum would have to be waived.

Experts from different ideologies generally agree that making this change wouldn't have major consequences. Best-case scenario, it would bring more young, healthy people into the marketplace. Worst-case scenario, is would siphon off some of these young, healthy people from more comprehensive plans, raising premiums for people still enrolled in them.

Here's what the experts said:

  • American Enterprise Institute's Joe Antos: "Adding a copper plan doesn't address the fundamental problem" of how the ACA deals with young, healthy people. "It's not just that they want a cheaper plan, it's that they want a cheaper plan that better fits their circumstances."
  • Levitt: "A copper plan, with lower premiums and higher deductibles, would modestly increase enrollment, particularly among healthier people. The effect wouldn't be huge, but it would move enrollment and the risk pool in the right direction."
  • Chris Jennings, a Democratic policy wonk: "The political question is this: Is the relatively harmlessness of the policy in real terms worth the time to develop, implement and confuse people (and in some cases get them mad) worth the political benefit of having more broad-based political investment in the Affordable Care Act?"
  • Brookings' Matthew Fiedler: If the plan is significantly less comprehensive than other options, "then there is a risk that it will siphon off healthier individuals from the existing metal tiers, driving up premiums for those plans, while leaving enrollees in the new copper tier with relatively weak protection against out-of-pocket costs."

Go deeper

Private equity hits the brakes amid coronavirus recovery uncertainties

Illustration: Rebecca Zisser/Axios

Private equity is still working on opportunistic deals when it can get a break from portfolio triage, but it's also boarding up the exits amid new questions about the speed of the coronavirus recovery.

The state of play: Sale processes are being shelved daily, even ones that already launched with investment bankers, data rooms, and interested suitors.

U.S. coronavirus updates: America's "very painful two weeks"

Data: The Center for Systems Science and Engineering at Johns Hopkins; Map: Andrew Witherspoon/Axios

The novel coronavirus has now killed more than 4,000 people in the U.S. — with over 1,500 deaths reported in New York City, per Johns Hopkins.

The state of play: In a major pivot in tone, President Trump said Tuesday it's "going to be a very painful two weeks," with projections indicating the virus could kill 100,000–240,000 Americans — even with strict social distancing guidelines in place.

Go deeperArrowUpdated 25 mins ago - Health

Why StubHub halted refunds

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios

With sports on pause and large gatherings banned across the globe, the live events industry has effectively ground to a halt.

The state of play: In the U.S. alone, more than 23,000 events have been canceled, postponed or rescheduled in the past three weeks.

Go deeperArrow58 mins ago - Sports