Sep 27, 2018

The unclear benefits of drug price coalitions

Illustration: Rebecca Zisser/Axios

Each of the predominant health care consulting firms — Aon, Mercer and Willis Towers Watson — has its own prescription drug coalition made up of employers. The conventional wisdom is firms use the combined scale to negotiate lower drug prices with large pharmacy benefit managers, but there's no hard evidence the coalitions provide meaningful savings.

What we're hearing: "The contracts are basically no different from what an individual company can get from a PBM, which means that all the individual company is doing is adding a layer of additional fees from the coalition," said Linda Cahn, an independent consultant who has reviewed coalition PBM contracts.

The details: The drug coalitions at Aon, Mercer and Willis Towers Watson include hundreds of companies and cover millions of workers. Employers don't have to enter one of the purchasing groups. But if they do, they may have to pay an additional fee and then contract with one of the three major PBMs — CVS Caremark, Express Scripts or OptumRx.

  • Drug benefits leaders at Mercer and Willis Towers Watson said the coalitions spawned from employer demand, believing a bigger group could yield bigger drug savings.
  • Those firms said they do not receive any direct or indirect compensation from PBMs to be exclusive vendors.
  • Aon turned down an interview and declined to answer written questions.

What we don't know: Whether the coalitions lead to the best rates for drugs, and whether employers could get better deals if they had negotiated outside of the coalitions.

  • Willis Towers Watson says its drug purchasing organization allows employers to "save 25% or more than their current contract," but there's no context behind that number. Benefits experts say employers often have no idea if the savings are true.
  • "Most of these PBM coalitions that are sponsored by consulting brokerages are just crap," said a source who has worked on pharmacy benefits for more than 20 years and has audited coalition contracts. "They never validate" how they save money, said the person, who asked not to be named to protect relationships.
  • CVS said in a statement that coalitions offer employers "better pricing and contract terms" than they would get on their own, but did not elaborate. Express Scripts said in a statement employers are able to audit contracts. OptumRx did not respond.

That's not all: Consulting firms often consider their own coalitions when they are running the bidding process for employers. Carmelina Rivera, a pharmacy consultant at Willis Towers Watson, said the firm keeps its financial and coalition people "independent from influences." But critics say it's a bad look.

  • Cahn manages her own employer drug coalition. However, Cahn said she will not include her coalition's bid if she's in charge of the employer's bidding process. "It's a ridiculous conflict of interest for a consulting firm to evaluate its own coalition's competitiveness," she said.

Go deeper

America's rundown roads add to farmers' struggles

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

American farmers are struggling to safely use the roads that cut through their fields; decades of neglect and lack of funding have made the routes dangerous.

The big picture: President Trump has long promised to invest billions in rural infrastructure, and his latest proposal would allocate $1 trillion for such projects. Rural America, where many of Trump's supporters live, would see a large chunk of that money.

South Korea and Italy see spikes in coronavirus cases

Data: The Center for Systems Science and Engineering at Johns Hopkins, the CDC, and China's Health Ministry. Note: China numbers are for the mainland only and U.S. numbers include repatriated citizens.

The novel coronavirus continues to spread to more nations, and the U.S. reports a doubling of its confirmed cases to 34 — while noting those are mostly due to repatriated citizens, emphasizing there's no "community spread" yet in the U.S. South Korea's confirmed cases jumped from 204 on Friday to 433 on Saturday, while Italy's case count rose from 3 to 62 as of Saturday.

The big picture: COVID-19 has now killed at least 2,362 people and infected more than 77,000 others, mostly in mainland China. New countries to announce infections recently include Israel, Lebanon and Iran.

Go deeperArrowUpdated 4 hours ago - Health

Centrist Democrats beseech 2020 candidates: "Stand up to Bernie" or Trump wins

Bernie Sanders rallies in Las Vegas, Nevada on Feb. 21. Photo: Mario Tama/Getty Images

Center-left think tank Third Way urgently called on the Democratic front-runners of the 2020 presidential election to challenge Sen. Bernie Sanders on the South Carolina debate stage on Feb. 25, in a memo provided to Axios' Mike Allen on Saturday.

What they're saying: "At the Las Vegas debate ... you declined to really challenge Senator Sanders. If you repeat this strategy at the South Carolina debate this week, you could hand the nomination to Sanders, likely dooming the Democratic Party — and the nation — to Trump and sweeping down-ballot Republican victories in November."