Jun 14, 2018

Certain rapid flu tests don't work half the time

Checking for the influenza virus at a research institute in Beijing, China, in 2018. Photo: Xinhua/Zhang Yuwei via Getty Images

A group of researchers confirmed via a study abstract what has been suggested by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention — rapid influenza antigen tests (RIATs) are not trustworthy because their sensitivity is too low.

Why it matters: 50% of patients infected with influenza may have had prolonged illness if they were initially misdiagnosed as flu-free and didn't receive the proper treatment, according to the abstract presented Sunday at the ASM Microbe 2018 conference.

"You have to be careful about relying heavily upon rapid flu tests."
— Anthony Fauci, director, National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases

Advice: Fauci told Axios that clinicians and patients should rely upon nasal swabs that look for influenza viral RNA or nucleic acids, or have their patient samples cultured for a couple days. But, treatment should not wait for cultured analysis, he added, because it's most effective at the beginning of the infection.

What the researchers did: Intensive care unit doctors in Taiwan started requiring virus cultures at the same time as RIATs. The team retrospectively analyzed the results for 307 patients with laboratory-confirmed influenza admitted to ICUs over a 10-year period, from August 2009 to July 2017.

What they found: "Decision-making based on RIAT is strongly discouraged and prompt empiric antiviral medication is justified in severe respiratory infection," the researchers say in the abstract, which is not yet peer-reviewed.

  • Out of the 307 cases, RIAT was checked for 259, and of those, 126 or 49% were wrongly labeled.
  • Patients who had tested negative for influenza using the RIAT, when compared to the RIAT-positive patients, had a longer average ICU stay of 12 days. This compared to an average length of stay of just 9 days for those labeled immediately positive.

Study limitations: Montreal Children's Hospital's Jesse Pappenburg, who was not part of the study, says "I agree that the scientific literature suggests that rapid diagnosis of influenza can improve patient outcomes through earlier antiviral treatment, especially among patients sick enough to be admitted to hospital."

However, he pointed out that it's difficult to analyze research without seeing the full study data. Pappenburg says he was surprised by the high rate of RIAT-negative samples that turned out to be positive cases, particularly since even during peak weeks of the flu season, only 30–50% of samples usually test positive.

"It may be that older, more severely ill patients are the ones that had false-negative RIAT results; they are also perhaps more likely to have more severe disease. However, it is impossible know because there is no information given comparing the baseline characteristics" of the study participants, Pappenburg says.

The most recent flu season, generally considered the worst one in 8 years, was confirmed by the CDC last week as a "high severity season." And, the cases identified as influenza are likely an underestimation, the CDC's report said, partly due to "poor reliability of rapid test results and greater reliance on clinical diagnosis for influenza."

What's next: The FDA recently reclassified rapid flu tests, so that new purchases must meet the minimum of more than 80% sensitivity.

"Traditional RIATs are still being used in the U.S. but we anticipate that they will be phased out as the U.S. FDA has reclassified influenza rapid tests," Pappenburg says. "Newer antigen detection tests with automated readers are becoming more and more popular and they have better performance than traditional RIATs."

Go deeper

Coronavirus updates: Market ends worst week since financial crisis

Data: The Center for Systems Science and Engineering at Johns Hopkins, the CDC, and China's Health Ministry. Note: China numbers are for the mainland only and U.S. numbers include repatriated citizens.

The stock market ended its worst week since the financial crisis, prompting the Fed to release a statement. Meanwhile, the WHO warned that countries are losing their chance to contain the novel coronavirus and raised its global risk assessment to "very high" Friday.

The big picture: COVID-19 has killed more than 2,860 people and infected more than 84,000 others in over 60 countries and territories outside the epicenter in mainland China. The number of new cases reported outside China now exceed those inside the country.

Go deeperArrowUpdated 10 hours ago - Health

California coronavirus: Latest case has no recent history of international travel

Gov. Gavin Newsom. Photo: Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images

A new case of the novel coronavirus in California was announced on Friday after Gov. Gavin Newsom said Thursday that 33 people had tested positive for the virus, noting the risk to the public remains low.

What's new: An adult woman with chronic health conditions in Santa Clara County who "did not recently travel overseas" or come into contact with anyone known to be ill was confirmed to have contracted the coronavirus on Friday by CDC and California Department of Public Health officials.

Go deeperArrowUpdated 10 hours ago - Health

Big video game conference delayed amid coronavirus concerns

Photo: GDC

Next month's Game Developers Conference in San Francisco became the latest tech event to be cancelled or postponed amid growing concerns over the spread of the novel coronavirus.

The big picture: A growing number of events are being scrapped, including Mobile World Congress and Facebook's F8 developer conference. Some, like the giant SXSW event in Austin, insist they are moving forward.