Medicaid expansion isn't a "slam dunk" for new Dem governors
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios
Democrats' sweeping electoral wins jump-started prospects for Medicaid expansion in red and purple states that rejected full expansions of the program under the Affordable Care Act.
- But budget realities could make newly elected Democratic governors pump the brakes.
Why it matters: The changing of the guard sets up a test of whether states can expand coverage to more low-income residents right after Republicans in Congress weakened financial incentives for doing so.
- States that are facing serious budget shortfalls and daunting cost projections already are signaling they may defer until conditions are more favorable.
State of play: Incoming Democratic governors in Wisconsin, Georgia, Texas and Kansas who campaigned on Medicaid expansion are now in a position to expand health coverage, and have more Democrats in their legislatures to help.
- Wisconsin Democrats have arguably the most leverage now that they've captured the state Senate and Assembly in addition to keeping control of the governor's office. Plus, the state already covers adults with incomes up to the federal poverty level.
- Expansion advocates in Georgia and Texas face a heavier lift, with Republicans still controlling at least one legislative chamber.
- And in Kansas, the GOP lost its supermajority in the House, a key obstacle in past Medicaid expansion fights, but still controls both chambers.
Between the lines: Each state faces unique considerations. But one thing is true for all of the holdouts: The incentives for expanding aren't what they used to be.
- Though the federal government still would pay for 90% of the expansion cost, last year's GOP reconciliation law made major policy changes and cuts to the program.
- Expansion states now face stricter limits on provider taxes used to finance Medicaid, as well as on extra payments they make to hospitals and other providers to go beyond standard Medicaid rates.
- They've also lost an important bonus: A temporary 5% increase in federal assistance for newly expanding states expired at the beginning of this year.
What's more, states will have to enforce new work requirements and document whether recipients perform 80 hours per month of work or other qualifying activities, or if they're subject to exemptions.
- While the Trump administration delayed the requirements for six months, they aren't likely to go away.
What they're saying: "You're going to see a lot of [expansion] conversations start, but I don't think they'll be slam dunks. It's complicated and nuanced," said Matt Salo, a health care consultant and former executive director of the National Association of Medicaid Directors.
- Incoming Wisconsin Gov. David Crowley already is acknowledging that reality and exploring alternatives for expanding coverage in the near term, including establishing a state-run health insurance exchange with a public option, per the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel.
- In Texas, some lawmakers are considering a "trigger" bill that would start an expansion only if the incoming Democratic majority in Congress succeeds in rolling back some of the restrictions in the federal law, the Texas Tribune reported.
- Georgia Gov.-elect Keisha Lance Bottoms intends to pursue a full expansion next year, but also wants to streamline the state's existing limited expansion program, called Pathways to Coverage, as an interim strategy until full expansion is achievable, the Atlanta Journal-Constitution reported.
Democratic victories in the Texas and Georgia lieutenant governor's races still could boost Medicaid expansion prospects, since the lieutenant governor presides over the state Senate in both states and influences which legislation is considered, Max Reale, an analyst for Gordon Haskett Research Advisors, wrote in a note.
- He pegged Wisconsin as the likeliest to expand its program and Kansas the long shot, since control of the governor's office alone failed to advance Medicaid expansion in past legislative sessions.
- But cementing the four as expansion states would diminish the prospects of further Medicaid cuts under a GOP-controlled Congress and free lawmakers to pressure the six remaining holdout states to adopt expansion post-2028, Reale said.
What we're watching: New Democratic governors in purple states that already expanded their Medicaid programs could also pursue changes, said Katie Keith, director of the Center for Health Policy and the Law at Georgetown's O'Neill Institute.
- She noted that Iowa Gov.-elect Rob Sand promised to end the state's contracts with three Medicaid managed care companies due to high rates of improper denials of care, and to have Iowa's Medicaid agency or a nonprofit take over processing and paying claims.
- Incoming officials in Iowa and Ohio could also go to court for relief from the most burdensome parts of the work rules, Keith wrote in Health Affairs.
