Albertans reject push for independence from Canada
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Annelise Capossela/Axios
Voters in oil-rich Alberta overwhelmingly rejected a push to bring the province one step closer to secession in a historic referendum.
Why it matters: The result is a win for Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney, who has touted a united, energy-dominant Canada and sought to appeal to Albertans, who have expressed resentment over the nation's energy policies.
- The defeat is a setback for the vocal separatist movement, which reached new fervor during the pandemic, but it's highly unlikely the independence push will vanish.
The big picture: Monday's vote was not a straight-forward yes or no on separating. Rather, it asked whether Alberta should remain part of Canada or start the legal process to hold another referendum on secession.
- 76% of voters opted to stay in Canada, as of the latest official tallies early Tuesday, as polls leading up to the vote suggested they would.
- ""On October 19, Albertans made a clear choice. They chose unity, to build together, and to take care of each other," the CBC quoted Carney as saying of the results.
Friction point: Alberta Premier Danielle Smith announced the separation vote in May to "understand the will" of Albertans "and move on."
- Smith, who has urged Albertans to vote to remain part of Canada, became a target of frustration from both sides.
- She said Albertans could still weigh in on the question after a court blocked a pro-independence petition, siding with First Nations leaders that argued the government failed to consult them about the impact on their treaty rights.
- Smith disagreed with that ruling.
The intrigue: Separatists leaders reportedly met with U.S. officials multiple times over the course of their campaign, and Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent publicly referred to Alberta as a "natural partner" for the U.S., drawing the ire of Canadian officials.
Zoom out: Despite the decisive vote, a majority of Albertans think the separatist movement will never end, per recent polling from the Angus Reid Institute.
- Movement leaders seem to agree.
- Keith Wilson, co-chair of the pro-independence group Let Alberta Decide, told supporters over the weekend that "regardless of what happens on Monday, we've already won" by the vote demonstrating a legal pathway to seceding.
- Overnight, Wilson told supporters the vote "concludes a campaign" but does not end the conversation, per the CBC.
The bottom line: In the face of a prolonged trade war with the U.S. and the potential secession vote, Carney consistently emphasized the importance of a united Canada's sovereignty.
- He's used that friction as a rallying cry. Speaking on a recent talk show appearance, Carney said "it's the worst of times" for international challenges, "but it's also the best of times in terms of opportunities for Alberta and for Canada."
- He compared the separatist push to the 2016 Brexit referendum, saying it's "a dangerous bluff."
Go deeper: Trump's Canada feud collides with Alberta's separatist vote
Editor's note: This story has been updated with new details throughout.
