People usually get the stock market wrong
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
The average American consumer thinks it’s unlikely the stock market will be higher 12 months from now.
Why it matters: Enthusiasm toward stocks is the kind of thing that inflates market bubbles that crash.
- On the other hand, caution toward stocks often means prices have room to go higher as that caution is eventually proven unwarranted.
By the numbers: Each month since June 2013, the Federal Reserve Bank of New York has asked consumers: "What do you think is the percent chance that 12 months from now, on average, stock prices in the U.S. stock market will be higher than they are now?"
- According to results released Monday, respondents in June said on average that there was a 40.2% likelihood that stocks would higher. That's down from 40.8% in May.
- The only time this measure was above 50% was in April 2020, right after the S&P 500 crashed to a low on March 23.
Yes, but: Ritholtz Wealth Management’s director of research, Michael Batnick, says history favors the optimists.
- "Going back to 1950, there was a 74.16% chance that the S&P 500 would be higher one year later," Batnick tells Axios.
- "When the S&P 500 was at an all-time high, there was a 74.10% chance the market was higher one year later."
What they’re saying: "Consumer sentiment is vulnerable to news items that report negative projections," Oppenheimer strategist John Stoltzfus tells Axios.
The bottom line: Just because people believe the stock market is unlikely to produce a positive return doesn’t mean it won’t produce a positive return.
