Axios Macro

September 19, 2024
The fallout from the Fed's extra-large rate cut yesterday is underway. Today, we read between the lines on what lies ahead for the central bank.
- Plus, how the White House and former president Donald Trump are talking about the onset of lower rates.
Situational awareness: The Bank of England elected to leave rates unchanged at a policy meeting today, as did central banks in Norway, Taiwan and Turkey. The Bank of Japan is next up, with a meeting Friday. 🇬🇧 🇳🇴 🇹🇼 🇹🇷 🇯🇵
Today's newsletter, edited by Kate Marino and copy edited by Anjelica Tan, is 804 words, a 3-minute read.
1 big thing: Recalibration nation
The Federal Reserve's half-point interest rate cut yesterday was a monetary policy mulligan, an extra golf swing when the first one didn't go quite the way the swinger intended.
The big picture: Chair Jerome Powell and his colleagues elected not to begin a rate cutting cycle at their last meeting back in July. Since then, job market data has come in a notch weaker than they expected. Yesterday's move aimed to make up for lost time.
- Both Powell's words and the written projections conveyed that Fed leadership sees the economy as basically sound and very much does not intend to cut rates by half a percent at every meeting.
- Rather, if the economy evolves as the central bank's leadership expects, the unemployment rate will level off only a bit higher than it is now — and we'll see quarter-point rate adjustments at the two remaining policy meetings this year, then four more quarter-point cuts in 2025.
Between the lines: Powell used some form of the word "recalibration" 10 times during his 49-minute news conference yesterday, one of many signs that Fed leadership is not viewing its extra-large cut as emergency response to incipient recession.
- Rather, the central bank is trying to adjust the dials to set monetary policy appropriately for an economic moment with inflation no longer at crisis levels.
What they're saying: "The U.S. economy is in good shape," Powell said in his news conference. "It's growing at a solid pace. Inflation is coming down. The labor market is in a strong place. We want to keep it there. That's what we're doing."
- He later acknowledged that they "might well have cut" two months ago if Fed officials had received a weak July jobs report before that month's policy meeting (the numbers came out two days later).
State of play: The unemployment rate is still low at 4.2%, but that is up from 3.7% at the start of the year, and the pace at which businesses are adding jobs has slowed substantially.
- The question now is whether Fed rate cuts will do the trick in stopping that deterioration from going much further. In projections released yesterday, Fed officials saw unemployment moving up slightly to 4.4% in the fourth quarter of this year — and still at that level at the end of 2025.
Reality check: Just because Powell and his colleagues don't expect to find themselves in emergency rate-cut mode doesn't mean it can't happen.
- In January 2001, the Fed started a rate cutting cycle with a half-point move. In the closed-door meeting, chair Alan Greenspan said that spokespeople "can convey that we're not all of a sudden signaling the prospect of a massive collapse in the federal funds rate."
- In fact, the Fed would cut rates 10 more times that year, bringing its target rate down from 6% to 1.75%.
2. Rate cut politics
Powell says politics don't factor into the Fed's policy decisions. Politicians, however, are looking to use the jumbo interest rate cut to their advantage.
Why it matters: The Fed's pivot to easier policy comes less than two months from an election where concerns about the economy and high costs are a top issue for voters.
Driving the news: As we hit send on today's newsletter, President Biden is set to talk about the economy before the Economic Club of Washington D.C.
- Biden is expected to tout how the administration — including Vice President Kamala Harris — has handled the economy. Lower interest rates, White House officials say, are part of that progress.
What they're saying: "Interest rates are following inflation down as well lowering costs for American consumers," Lael Brainard, a top White House economic advisor, told reporters yesterday afternoon not long after Powell's news conference concluded.
- "Americans have been through a lot, and the declines in interest rates and in inflation will provide relief by making things more affordable — from refinancing a home to buying a car," Brainard added.
The intrigue: White House officials said Biden has stuck to an earlier pledge to respect the Fed's political independence.
- But they added that it was important to acknowledge that Americans are getting relief from a decline in inflation and interest rates.
- Officials also brushed off concerns about the labor market, pointing to Powell's assertion that the job market is solid.
The other side: Trump, who appointed Powell in 2017, told reporters yesterday that the half-point cut meant "the economy is very bad to cut it by that much, assuming they're not just playing politics."
The bottom line: There is nothing to back up the assertion that the Fed's decision was political — and it's unlikely the rate cut will have an immediate impact before the election.
- "I would also point out that the things that we do really affect economic conditions, for the most part, with a lag," Powell told reporters.
Sign up for Axios Macro




