Axios Macro

September 09, 2025
You can't properly look forward without also knowing what happened in the past.
- Today, we have an uncommonly backward-looking edition of Macro, based on two major data releases this morning that change our understanding of the 2024 economy.
- Turns out, it featured weaker job growth than was previously known, and stagnant incomes for the middle class.
Today's newsletter, edited by Ben Berkowitz and copy edited by Katie Lewis, is 751 words, a 3-minute read.
1 big thing: Jobs growth was much slower than it looked
The job market was showing cracks earlier than previously known, according to highly anticipated revisions released this morning.
Why it matters: The data shifts the understanding of how the labor market performed in 2024 through earlier this year.
- It confirms the hiring slowdown has been underway for some time, raising the stakes that the economy's weakening trend might continue.
What they're saying: "[T]he slower job creation implies income growth was also on a softer footing even prior to the recent rise in policy uncertainty and economic slowdown we've seen since the spring," Nationwide's financial market economist Oren Klachkin wrote in a note.
By the numbers: The economy added 911,000 fewer jobs in the 12 months ending in March 2025 than first estimated, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said in preliminary revisions.
- The revisions were steepest, in percentage terms, in the information sector (down 2.3%), wholesale trade (-1.8%) and leisure and hospitality (-1.1%).
- The revisions were larger than the downward adjustment of 700,000 that economists anticipated.
How it works: The BLS compiles monthly jobs reports based on surveys from households and businesses. The agency updates that data, on a lag, with more complete information from unemployment insurance tax records.
- This report — the Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages — can show drastic revisions of previously released data.
The intrigue: When the revisions are officially worked into the payrolls numbers starting early next year, average monthly job growth over the April 2024 to March 2025 period will be 71,000 — half of what was first reported.
Of note: In recent weeks, Trump administration officials have used the BLS' revision procedures as a cudgel to attack government statistics, and the new benchmark revisions are no exception.
- "Today's massive downward revision gives the American people even more reason to doubt the integrity of data being published by BLS," Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer said in a statement.
- "[T]here is no room for such a significant and consistent amount of error. It's imperative for the data to remain accurate, impartial, and never altered for political gain," she added. BLS is under her purview, though it has long been run by career technocrats.
- President Trump has seized on data from previous QCEW reports, suggesting — without evidence — the figures were politicized. Last month, he fired the BLS commissioner after revisions showed disappointing job growth over the summer.
Yes, but: It is not uncommon for the BLS to dramatically revise jobs growth — though the downward revision of 911,000 jobs is the largest on record. That figure will be revised once more early next year.
- Like other statistical agencies around the world, the BLS has been plagued by low survey response rates that can result in revisions down the line. Shifts in the economic backdrop can also undermine the agency's models.
- "In steady times, their assumptions are accurate, but at turning points in the cycle they can be significantly wrong," ING chief international economist James Knightley wrote in a note.
The bottom line: The labor market cracks are not new, though they have continued as employers are strained by trade and immigration policies.
2. A good year for the already comfortable


Middle-income U.S. households saw essentially flat incomes last year. The affluent saw a significant pay bump.
- That's a key takeaway from the Census Bureau's annual report on income, poverty, and health insurance coverage out this morning.
By the numbers: The median U.S. household's income was $83,730 in 2024, an inflation-adjusted 1.3% bump that the Census Bureau said was not statistically different from $82,690 in 2023.
- However, at the top of the income distribution — the 90th percentile — inflation-adjusted income rose 4.2% to $251,000.
- Incomes at the 10th percentile were up 2.2% to $19,900.
- The poverty rate fell 0.4 percentage point to 10.6%.
Of note: There were big differences among racial groups. Median income increased by 5.5% among Hispanics from 2023 to 2024, 5.1% among Asian-Americans, and 1.4% among white Americans.
- Median income fell 3.3% in inflation-adjusted terms for Black Americans.
The bottom line: With middle-income earners seeing modest to non-existent income bumps last year, it is less surprising that public opinion on the economy remained sharply negative.
Sign up for Axios Macro



