Axios Capital

April 07, 2022
Hi there Axios Capital readers! It is I, Felix Salmon, back at the helm of this trusty vessel. Many thanks to the incomparable Neil Irwin for doing such a great job steering it while I was away.
- Neil's still writing up a storm, but for this week at least, Axios Capital will have absolutely nothing on economics or monetary policy. It's also shorter than it used to be: I learned during my months off how important the "brevity" part of "smart brevity" really is.
- This week's newsletter — about charitable donations, blockchain-based art certificates, and Elon Musk — is just 1,545 words long, a 6-minute read.
1 big thing: Ukraine's philanthropic tailwinds
Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios
The humanitarian emergency in Ukraine has led to a global outpouring of support. In times of crisis, the feeling that you're looking on helplessly at atrocities is partially assuaged when there are actually ways to help, at least a little.
Why it matters: That impulse is a philanthropic one. All philanthropies are constantly on the hunt for government funding — and in this case the government funding is already there, to the tune of many billions of dollars. That can change the calculus of where to give.
How it works: Broadly speaking, there are two different ways that individuals are helping Ukraine.
- Go small: Buy from Amazon wish lists. Send packages. Donate bitcoin. Book Airbnbs. Transfer money directly to individuals. Help teams find shelter in Poland for grandma.
- Go big: Find an organization committed to helping millions of Ukrainians, not just a few, and give to them. If in doubt, look for alphabet soup: ICRC, IFRC, WFP, IRC, UNICEF.
Going small has the advantage that it's much easier to see or imagine the way in which your donation can help a specific individual. It feels real and concrete.
- Donations of cash are extraordinarily versatile, and will be used for immediate unforeseeable needs. If you donate stuff, by contrast, there's a lot of uncertainty as to when and whether it will ever arrive, and also whether it will still be needed when does. Plus a lot of your money will disappear into retail markups and transportation costs.
Going big means economies of scale, and a higher probability of reaching groups who don't have online connections. Often the neediest individuals can be the hardest to find. Large organizations like IRC also give out cash directly.
The big picture: The vast majority of aid to Ukraine is coming from governments, not individuals. They have mobilized sums that would be impossible to raise from the private sector.
- By the numbers: Congress approved $13.6 billion in aid for Ukraine in mid-March, and more money has been unlocked since then. Other countries are also contributing aid measured in the hundreds of millions of dollars, with the EU alone giving billions.
Be smart: When individuals donate to a large international organization, they're not only supporting efforts on the ground. They're also supporting those organizations' efforts to raise money from governments around the world — efforts which, in the case of Ukraine, have already raised billions of dollars and are likely to raise billions more.
- Ask yourself this: Would you rather spend $100,000 on the needy in Ukraine, or spend $100,000 persuading the US government to authorize another $100 million for the needy in Ukraine? With donations to places like WFP or IRC, your money gets used in both ways, wherever it can be put to best use.
The bottom line: Sometimes it can feel as though high-profile ad campaigns from places like IRC are costing money that could otherwise be spent directly on refugees. But those campaigns don't just raise money, they raise support at grassroots level — support that can end up being worth billions when trying to extract money from Congress.
2. Food leverage
Shoshana Gordon/Axios
My most recent charitable donation was to WFP USA, the U.S. fundraising arm of the UN's World Food Programme. (It also operates as ShareTheMeal.)
- The WFP operates mostly in the developing world, but it also has an ambitious plan to provide food and cash to more than 3 million people inside Ukraine, as well as 300,000 refugees and asylum seekers. That kind of scale requires major government support.
Why it matters: At first glance, WFP USA doesn't look like it's particularly efficient. According to its most recent financial statement, in the year ending in September 2021, it raised $61.4 million from the public, while passing through just 62% of that amount — $37.9 million — to the WFP itself.
- Both those numbers were more than double the amounts raised in the previous year, ending September 2020. And they will easily be surpassed again this year. WFP USA has already raised $30 million in private donations for Ukraine alone, just since the beginning of the conflict.
- The really big number, however, is $3.8 billion, or $3,765,625,520 to be precise. That's the amount of money the U.S. government gave to the WFP in 2021. It's not only more than 60 times the total sum raised by WFP USA that year, it also represents an increase of more than $100 million from the equivalent number in 2020.
How it works: The money raised by WFP USA but not passed through to WFP isn't wasted. The U.S. organization has two other parts of its mission:
- The communications function is aimed at trying to "expand U.S. government and private sector support for solving global hunger."
- The policy function is designed to educate "members of Congress and other officials about international hunger issues."
What's happening: The U.S. government has already given the WFP more than $50 million for its Ukraine efforts, easily eclipsing all the private-sector donations to WFP USA combined.
The bottom line: I want my donation to maximize the amount of food aid being delivered to Ukraine and the rest of the world. The best way to achieve that is to get the U.S. government to match my donation 60-to-1.
3. A central clearinghouse for art transactions
Illustration: Annelise Capossela/Axios
The art market is notorious for its opacity and confidentiality. That makes it effectively impossible to track artworks in a way that ensures their authenticity — and also creates insurmountable difficulties for anybody trying to get artists paid when their work goes up in value.
What we're watching: A new startup called Fairchain aims to change all that.
How it works: Fairchain is setting itself up as an art-world clearinghouse that artists, collectors and galleries can trust with highly confidential information about the price and ownership of artworks.
- Artists use Fairchain to generate a digital certificate of authenticity without which the artwork is worthless. The certificate can only be transferred to a new owner if that person signs a contract promising the artist a royalty payment — normally 10% or less — on all future resales.
- When the artwork is resold, the buyer only receives the all-important certificate of authenticity after they've signed the contract and the royalty payment has been made, normally via Fairchain.
- Fairchain needs to know the identity of the buyer and the amount that the work sold for, but that information is kept strictly confidential. Max Kendrick, Fairchain's CEO, tells Axios even he doesn't have access to it.
Between the lines: Fairchain makes use of the immutability of the Ethereum blockchain to generate an unforgeable chain of provenance all the way back to the artist's studio. The digital certificate of authenticity will not, however, reveal the identity of previous owners, nor how much they paid for the work.
- The certificate comes with high-resolution photographs of the front and back of the work, making it much easier for an appraiser to determine whether a piece is authentic.
The intrigue: Dealers in general dislike any system that institutionalizes knowledge they used to have to themselves, or that might make it harder to sell a work. Some smaller gallerists, however, have embraced Fairchain because it allows them to bake in a small resale royalty for themselves, along with the artist.
- Parts of the system can theoretically be circumvented: Buyers and sellers could conspire to lie about the value of a transaction, for instance. But the whole point of Fairchain, per Kendrick, is in large part to create "social expectations and norms" around paying artists when works are resold.
The bottom line: It's very early days yet, but Fairchain contracts already accompany works by artists including Eric Fischl, Marilyn Minter, and Duke Riley.
4. Elon Musk's power grab
Photo illustration: Shoshana Gordon/Axios. Photo: Christian Marquardt - Pool/Getty Images
Elon Musk is now officially ensconced as the richest person in the world. By using his social and financial clout to muscle his way onto the board of Twitter, he's working hard to become a full-fledged mogul, generously endowed with all three parts of the great trinity of money, fame and power.
Why it matters: Musk accumulated his money through Tesla and SpaceX. He accumulated much of his fame through Twitter. Now he's working on power, the rarest component of the three.
The big picture: Musk now has partial control of an entire social network — one that is powerful enough to have propelled Donald Trump to the presidency of the United States. He's rarely satisfied with partial control of anything.
- The intrigue: Musk in December compared Twitter CEO Parag Agrawal to Josef Stalin, which may or may not be a lesser insult than "pedo guy".
How it works: Musk has a close friendship and affinity with Jack Dorsey, the only Twitter co-founder on the board of directors. The two of them could easily execute a plan to take Twitter private, but given their influence at board level, that might not even be necessary.
The bottom line: Mark Zuckerberg is not the richest person in the business world, but he is the most powerful, thanks to his control of Facebook. Elon Musk, if he ends up controlling Twitter, could rival Zuckerberg's power.
5. Billionaire consumption goods, ranked*
Illustration: Annelise Capossela/Axios
*This ranking is highly scientific and objective, and brooks no whimsy.




