Last week, Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s government announced annual cash transfers to India's massive population of small and marginal farmers. The move comes days after a vow by the opposition party — Indian National Congress (INC) — to guarantee a minimum income for every poor Indian if voted to power in upcoming parliamentary elections.

Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi speaks in Kashmir, India. Photo: Faisal Khan/NurPhoto via Getty Images

Why it matters: Universal basic income has emerged as a major battleground in Indian politics. The fate of either party’s proposal will influence not only the trajectory of India’s development, but also the global popularity of the idea, which is touted as the antidote to both poverty and technology-driven unemployment.

Background: Basic income proposals have proliferated in India amid widespread rural distress and growing despair about welfare programs long plagued by corruption and inefficiency.

  • Supporters argue that direct cash payments to bank accounts will better reach beneficiaries, eliminate middlemen and streamline public finances.
  • Critics worry about underinvestment in core public services, the Indian state’s limited capacity to distribute large-scale transfers and the political difficulty of rolling back existing programs.

Details: Successfully establishing a targeted basic income will involve a historic reorganization of India’s welfare state. Voters will weigh each plan's transfer size and frequency, eligibility criteria, and implementation relative to existing public programs.

  • The Modi administration will provide 120 million small agricultural households with an annual transfer of $84. The program's biggest challenge is sufficiency: With the payout equaling less than 1% of both the average income and debt of eligible households, it may be too little too late for India's agrarian crisis.
  • The INC's proposal is more ambitious, potentially reaching 300 million poor Indians. It would first establish a national minimum-income level and then transfer to each individual the difference between their income and that threshold. But this could present challenges for the Indian state, as administrative delays are frequent even among programs with fixed payments and clearly identifiable populations.

The bottom line: With unemployment at a 45-year high, and more than half of all farming households in debt, there is a growing political consensus that direct cash support would eradicate poverty faster than traditional welfare. Whatever decision voters make will have major implications for both India's civilian population and its politicians.

Saksham Khosla is a master's candidate in international economics and international development at the Johns Hopkins University School of Advanced International Studies and a former research analyst at Carnegie India.

Go deeper

Updated 2 hours ago - Politics & Policy

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 12 p.m. ET: 10,920,457 — Total deaths: 522,385 — Total recoveries — 5,789,032Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 12 p.m. ET: 2,753,754 — Total deaths: 128,871 — Total recoveries: 781,970 — Total tested: 33,462,181Map.
  3. Public health: The states where face coverings are mandatory Fauci says it has been a "very disturbing week" for the spread of the coronavirus in the U.S.
  4. Business: Top business leaders urge the White House to develop mandatory mask guidelines.
  5. Economy: The economy may recover just quickly enough to kill political interest in more stimulus.
  6. States: Florida reports more than 10,000 new coronavirus cases, and its most-infected county issues curfew.
3 hours ago - Sports

Washington Redskins to review team name amid public pressure

Photo: Patrick McDermott/Getty Images

The Washington Redskins have announced they will be conducting a review of the team's name after mounting pressure from the public and corporate sponsors.

Why it matters: This review is the first formal step the Redskins are taking since the debate surrounding the name first began. It comes after weeks of discussions between the team and the NFL, the team said.

Scoop: Instacart raises another $100 million

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios Visuals

Grocery delivery company Instacart has raised $100 million in new funding, on top of the $225 million it announced last month, the company tells Axios. This brings its valuation to $13.8 billion.

Why it matters: This funding comes at what could be an inflection point for Instacart, as customers it acquired during coronavirus lockdowns decide whether they want to continue with the service or resume in-person grocery shopping.