Illustration: Sarah Grillo / Axios

AT&T spent Monday on a final aggressive attempt to undermine the foundation of the Justice Department’s case to block its proposed $85 billion purchase of Time Warner, while government lawyers looked to cement their case by destroying the company’s credibility.

The bottom line: The closing arguments set the stage for Judge Richard J. Leon's decision after the more than six-week-long trial, which will send waves rippling through the tech, telecom and media industries— and likely affect the millions of consumers who use these companies' products.

What's next: Leon said he expected to deliver a ruling on June 12, although that date could be moved up if he makes a decision sooner. The termination date for the deal to close is June 21.

The details:

  • The government argued that the only way to address the problems with the deal was to block it. If the judge didn't go that far, Justice Department lawyers urged him to make AT&T sell DirecTV, its video distribution platform, or some of the Time Warner content that, they alleged, would give it leverage over competitors in that video space. “Your honor,” said lead government lawyer Craig Conrath, “this merger is a big deal.”
  • Conrath said that AT&T’s promises not to engage in anti-competitive behavior were undermined by its executives' own statements.
  • AT&T and Time Warner argued that the economic model the Justice Department used to estimate that consumer bills will rise after the merger was irredeemably flawed. And so, their lead lawyer Daniel Petrocelli said, the government's entire case was as well.
  • "This whole case is a house of cards," he said. "The model makes no sense. The model is not consistent with the real world."

Buzz: The closing day of the trial brought big names to the courthouse, including AT&T CEO Randall Stephenson and Time Warner CEO Jeff Bewkes.

  • Andrew Finch, a top lieutenant in the Justice Department’s antitrust division, sat with the government’s litigators at their table in front of the judge.
  • At lunch, ahead of his closing arguments, Petrocelli huddled with Stephenson and AT&T General Counsel David McAtee in the courthouse cafeteria, while Bewkes carried out a conversation several tables away. Both stayed in the courtroom into the afternoon session.

Go deeper

BodyArmor takes aim at Gatorade's sports drink dominance

Illustration: Eniola Odetunde/Axios

BodyArmor is making noise in the sports drink market, announcing seven new athlete partnerships last week, including Christian McCaffrey, Sabrina Ionescu and Ronald Acuña Jr.

Why it matters: It wants to market itself as a worthy challenger to the throne that Gatorade has occupied for nearly six decades.

S&P 500's historic rebound leaves investors divided on future

Data: Money.net; Chart: Axios Visuals

The S&P 500 nearly closed at an all-time high on Wednesday and remains poised to go from peak to trough to peak in less than half a year.

By the numbers: Since hitting its low on March 23, the S&P has risen about 50%, with more than 40 of its members doubling, according to Bloomberg. The $12 trillion dollars of share value that vanished in late March has almost completely returned.

Newsrooms abandoned as pandemic drags on

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

Facing enormous financial pressure and uncertainty around reopenings, media companies are giving up on their years-long building leases for more permanent work-from-home structures. Others are letting employees work remotely for the foreseeable future.

Why it matters: Real estate is often the most expensive asset that media companies own. And for companies that don't own their space, it's often the biggest expense.