Why the oil price surge (probably) won't bring a U.S. drilling surge
Add Axios as your preferred source to
see more of our stories on Google.
Illustration: Lindsey Bailey/Axios
Oil prices at four-year highs (and maybe climbing further) might nudge record U.S. production even higher — but don't expect a new boom.
Why it matters: Companies in onshore shale — the most nimble part of the industry — need lots of convincing to invest far beyond current plans, analysts say.
The big picture: Several interlocking reasons will limit how much even very high prices will affect U.S. production.
- One is that nobody knows how long the war that's now throttling Middle East supplies will last.
- Companies are watching a forward price curve that, for now, sees decline months down the road.
Flashback: Another reason is scar tissue. Producers and investors remember the wreckage of the debt-fueled, growth-above-all 2010s era.
- "Today's public [exploration and production] companies are no longer cowboys willing to blast off billions in capex because of a 'hunch,'" veteran analyst Dan Pickering said in a blog post.
- Capital discipline, investor payouts, and bolstering balance sheets remain today's priorities as companies are in line for a windfall.
Still another factor is more moment-specific.
- Prices were quite modest in 2025. Producers are now "especially ill-equipped to respond to high prices this year," said Rystad Energy analyst Matthew Bernstein.
- Last year's focus was to maintain production and investor payouts — which meant fewer drilling rigs, drawing on balance sheets, and relying on already drilled-but-uncompleted wells (DUCs), he tells Axios.
- That leaves fewer of these DUCs available to quickly bring online now.
What we're watching: The crisis will probably have some effect on producers' capital spending as U.S. output sits at a world-leading 13.7 million barrels per day.
- Already, the Energy Department's stats and analysis arm revised its outlook from a slight decline next year to a slight rise instead.
- The Iran war could change the outlook a bit, but analysts aren't expecting the kind of huge surges common in the 2010s and the post-COVID rebound.
What they're saying: Jenna Delaney, an upstream analyst with Rapidan Energy Group, sees U.S. crude oil and natural gas liquids rising 200,000 barrels per day this year and staying steady in 2027 on the strength of higher prices.
- Her prior outlook saw flat production in 2026 and a decline next year.
- "I still expect companies to be conservative with production this year and focus on their balance sheets, but we're now more likely to see production at the upper end of producer guidance," she said via email.
Zoom out: Shale producers had budgeted for WTI prices in the $55-60 range, Rystad's Bernstein said in a note.
- He and others say major plan revisions are unlikely unless it's clear that high prices will remain for months.
- Remember that until this war, the dominant market narrative was one of oversupply.
Yes, but: A long and even more damaging crisis could bring a different calculus.
- Pickering writes that a "clear geopolitical signal that higher prices will be structural" would be among the forces that bring shale companies "off the fence."
- Rystad also sees scenarios where the conflict boosts production.
- Yet wild cards abound. Prices that reach and remain in the stratosphere could trigger "demand destruction."
The bottom line: "Nobody is rushing to make any decisions right now in response to the higher prices," said Bernstein, the Rystad analyst.
Sign up here for Axios' Future of Energy newsletter.
