Nov 6, 2017

The irony in Trump's anti-ACA moves

Caitlin Owens, author of Vitals

Ending subsidy payments could help make part of the ACA better. Photo: Andrew Harnik/AP

President Trump's decision to quit paying a critical Affordable Care Act subsidy has given most of the country access to insurance with no monthly premiums — nudging it, however inelegantly, in the same direction Democrats have wanted to go (at least for the poorest enrollees).

The bottom line, from Democratic health care strategist Chris Jennings: "The R's are driving in reverse relative to their repeal dream."

How it works: When Trump decided to quit making payments to insurers for the ACA's cost-starring reduction (CSR) subsidies, insurers responded by raising their premiums for certain plans — mostly, the "benchmark" plans that are used to determine the size of the ACA's premium subsidies.

  • That, in turn, made those subsidies much more generous.
  • And now, in most counties in the U.S., the lowest-income enrollees will be able to find at least one plan for which their subsidy covers the entire premium.
  • "In a way, this was an incredibly complicated and convoluted way of increasing the premium subsidies available to consumers," said Larry Levitt of the Kaiser Family Foundation.
  • But people who don't receive subsidies could have to pay substantially more. And this backwards stumble into higher subsidy is still a net negative for insurers, who crave stability most of all.

What they're saying:

  • "The ACA was designed to protect low income consumers from situations like this-- as improbable as this one was," said Andy Slavitt, the former Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services under President Obama. But "for people without subsidies, Trump's action disproportionately hurt those in the middle class."
  • Topher Spiro, of the Center for American Progress: "People can get better deals, but not unless they shop around—and there's mass confusion as a result of sabotage. So far, no insurers have pulled out, but continued uncertainty means there's a risk of insurers exiting for 2019—or not re-entering markets."

Reality check: The irony of all this is that Democrats — including Hillary Clinton — have consistently pushed for increased premium subsidies, albeit in a much more straightforward way. (And of course they also want the government to continue the payments Trump cut off.)

  • "We could spend that extra money we are shelling out today to pay for the excess premiums far more efficiently and get more people covered more affordably," Jennings said.
  • Congressional Republicans would never have agreed to create more "free" insurance plans on the government's dime. Their repeal-and-replace bills would have substantially reduced the law's premium subsidies. But many experts think higher subsides will help. "That's what it's going to take to make the ACA work," said Chris Condeluci, a former Republican aide on the Finance Committee.

Go deeper

Updated 35 mins ago - Politics & Policy

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 11:30 a.m. ET: 5,850,258 — Total deaths: 361,249 — Total recoveries — 2,444,898Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 11:30 a.m. ET: 1,724,873 — Total deaths: 101,698 — Total recoveries: 399,991 — Total tested: 15,646,041Map.
  3. Public health: Hydroxychloroquine prescription fills exploded in March —How the U.S. might distribute a vaccine.
  4. Business: Many poor and minority families can't afford food or rent.
  5. 2020: Trump courts Asian American vote amid coronavirus.
  6. ⚽️ Sports: European soccer's push to return.

Trump's big, empty beef with Twitter

Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios

President Trump finally acted on his now year-old threat to take action against social media platforms for alleged bias against conservatives. But so far, according to experts in both government and the industry, the threat looks mostly empty.

Driving the news: Trump escalated his war on Twitter Friday morning, tweeting repeatedly that the company needs to be regulated after it overnight added a warning label to a tweet of his calling for the military to start shooting looters, which violated Twitter’s rules against glorifying violence.

In photos: Protests over George Floyd's death grip Minneapolis

The Third Police Precinct burns in Minneapolis on Thursday night. Photo: Stephen Maturen/Getty Images

Demonstrators demanding justice burned a Minneapolis police station and took control of the streets around it last night, heaving wood onto the flames, kicking down poles with surveillance cameras and torching surrounding stores.

What's happening: The crowd was protesting the death of George Floyd, an unarmed black man whose life was snuffed out Tuesday by a white Minneapolis police officer who kneeled on his neck for about eight minutes.