India opened up restaurants, shopping malls and places of worship today even as it recorded a record-high 9,971 new coronavirus cases, the third-most new cases today behind Brazil and the U.S.
Why it matters: Lockdowns are being lifted in South Asia — home to one-quarter of the world’s population — not because countries are winning the battle against COVID-19, but because they simply can't sustain them any longer.
Flashback: Until last month, South Asia was a source of optimism because relatively few cases and deaths were being recorded despite large, dense populations.
- Lockdowns came relatively early, with varying severity (India’s was considerably stricter than Pakistan’s, for example).
- Outbreaks have continued to accelerate, however. Pakistan’s daily case count is now on par with the U.K.'s and six times Germany's, adjusted for population.
Limited testing means South Asia's outbreaks could actually be far more severe. India, for example, is testing at one-twentieth the rate of the U.S.
- John Clemens, an epidemiologist at ICDDR,B (formerly the International Centre for Diarrhoeal Disease Research, Bangladesh), estimates that Bangladesh's capital, Dhaka, may have up to 750,000 cases — 12 times the official tally, per the Economist.
- The official numbers still show India, Pakistan and Bangladesh with the third-, seventh- and tenth-most new cases in the world over the past three days, respectively.
Bhramar Mukherjee, a professor at the University of Michigan who has been modeling India's outbreak, tells Axios that while some states have hit initial peaks, she doesn't expect a national peak until late July or August.
- The numbers can be unreliable, Mukherjee says, with some states having a perverse incentive to test fewer people to keep their numbers from spiking.
- She also worries that India didn't use the lockdown period to build up testing and hospital capacity.
- "It's really chaos unfolding in Mumbai and Delhi, and I think unfortunately India is going to be at the top of the list in terms of cases," she says.
Zoom in: Mumbai has launched an app to help people locate hospitals with empty beds, but such is the scarcity that they’re often full by the time patients arrive, WSJ reports. Some die without ever receiving treatment.
- Morgues are overfull t00. There are reports of patients being treated in rooms that also contain dead bodies.
- Public hospitals in Delhi, home to 26 million people, are also reportedly full and turning people away.
The coronavirus likely arrived in Mumbai with wealthy people returning from abroad, before spreading among poorer people and to slums where social distancing is hardly an option.
- That pattern has been seen elsewhere in the developing world, including in cities like Rio de Janeiro.
- There's an additional complication in India's case, though. After initially failing to account for migrant workers when implementing the lockdown, the government started to transport them to their home villages on special busses and trains.
- The virus traveled too. 71% of cases recorded in Bihar, a state in eastern India, have been linked to returning workers, Foreign Policy reports.
The bottom line: South Asian governments attempted to balance health and hunger, knowing they could only shut down their largely informal economies for so long.
- But with health care systems already stretched and case counts continuing to rise, they're opening up with more hope than confidence.