May 04, 2020

⚾️ Good morning! When devoted fans describe their love of baseball, they do so with a reverence that can sound absurd to the uninitiated. There is a mystique to the game, a feeling. And this morning, we are leaning all the way into it.

  • Heads up: Over the next 30 editions of Axios Sports, we'll be ranking the all-time rosters for all 30 MLB teams, starting with the worst and ending with the best. Check item No. 9 to see who ranks last.
  • We'll dive back into the daily news cycle tomorrow. Today is all about an escape into the realm of sports we're missing right now, and the magic and nostalgia of it all. Please enjoy, and we hope you have a great start to your week. — Kendall (@thekendallbaker) and Jeff (@JeffreyTracy)

📆 Deep Dive schedule:

  • Today: ⚾️ Baseball in America
  • Next Monday: 👶 COVID-19's impact on youth sports
  • Monday, May 18: 🎬 The 50 best sports docs ever
  • Monday, May 25: ⁉️ Mystery

Today's word count: 2,167 words (8 minutes).

1 big thing: 🇺🇸 Baseball in America

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

It's been 54 days since we last had sports in this country — and 187 days since we last had baseball.

Why it matters: That's a long time to go without our national pastime. In fact, unless baseball returns before July 15, we are living through the longest MLB outage in history (current record: 257 days during the 1994-95 strike).

The big picture: While MLB's impending return drives the news, there is an entire world of baseball beyond the big leagues that has also been impacted by the coronavirus pandemic.

  • From the minor leagues to college, all the way down to high school and little league, baseball — and softball — are not being played anywhere right now.

The impact: There are more important things than baseball right now. We all understand that. But that doesn't mean baseball isn't important. Of course it is.

  • Think of the millions of children who play youth baseball and softball, and the memories they may not get the chance to make this summer. Think of their parents, the coaches, the volunteer umpires, the ice cream truck. Things may never be the same.
  • Think of the hundreds of thousands of high school baseball and softball players who saw their seasons — and, for some of them, their athletic careers — disappear into thin air. Glory days, interrupted.
  • Think of the tens of thousands of college players who trained all year only to see their campuses shutter in a matter of days. "The worst part is the lack of closure. I just wish I'd known that was our last game together, ya know? It feels incomplete. That was my family," one Big Ten player told me.
  • Think of the thousands of minor league players who are being paid $400 per week while the season is on hiatus and their futures sit in limbo.

The bottom line: Baseball's rich history binds together generations, and the role it plays in childhood and in cinema makes it the most nostalgic of all sports.

  • Without it, many are lost, with no games to watch or listen to as background noise, and no Opening Day or annual double-header to mark the passage of time between spring and summer.
"It is a cruel twist of biology that the social distancing required in response to the COVID-19 epidemic has also necessarily robbed us of baseball, something that might help to heal our souls."
— Franklin H. Zimmerman, NYT

2. 🌊 The Cape Cod League

Logos: SportsLogos.Net; Map: Andrew Witherspoon/Axios

Every summer, the nation's top college stars arrive in Massachusetts to play in the Cape Cod League — a magical circuit that epitomizes America's love affair with baseball and is like something out of a Norman Rockwell painting. Sadly, they had to cancel the 2020 season.

  • The history: The CCBL was founded in 1885 but was limited to Cape Cod residents until 1963 when it was officially sanctioned by the NCAA and began recruiting college players.
  • The prestige: Over a thousand MLB players have spent at least one summer on the Cape, including Hall of Famers Carlton Fisk, Frank Thomas, Craig Biggio and Jeff Bagwell.
House on Cape Cod
Photo: Simon M. Bruty/AnyChance Productions/Getty Images

The teams: There are 10 teams representing 10 small towns, all within an hour drive of each other. Vacationers and residents often have strong allegiances toward their home team, hanging signs in their front yards and talking baseball over breakfast.

  • East Division: Brewster Whitecaps, Chatham Anglers, Harwich Mariners, Orleans Firebirds, Yarmouth-Dennis Red Sox
  • West Division: Bourne Braves, Cotuit Kettleers, Falmouth Commodores, Hyannis Harbor Hawks, Wareham Gatemen
Cape Cod League players celebrating
Photo: Maddie Meyer/Getty Images

The players: The CCBL is the first time most college players get the chance to hit with a wooden bat against consistently strong pitching. They play almost every day during a 44-game regular-season schedule, all while living with host families and working on the side (i.e. bagging groceries).

"Every single player on my Orleans team except for three guys played professionally. All the teams are like this, too. And there are tons of scouts on the Cape for the summer, so the loss of the 2020 season means a lot of players sadly won't get the opportunity to be seen."
— Jordan Betts, former Red Sox minor leaguer and CCBL "graduate"
Fans at a baseball game
Photo: Simon M. Bruty/AnyChance Productions/Getty Images

The ballparks: Every team's home field differs in a variety of ways, adding to the charm. The Chatham Anglers, for instance, have a gorgeous stadium that seats 8,000 people, while the Orleans Firebirds play at a middle school.

"You go to Wareham and the dirt is gray. You play at our park in Orleans and it's really short down the lines and its 415 in center. You play in Chatham, you have to worry about the fog rolling in. They all have so much character, and there's just this deep sense of nostalgia and mystique."
— Betts
Woman painting at a baseball game
Photo: Maddie Meyer/Getty Images

The setting: Families sharing a blanket on the brim of a grassy knoll. Kids playing catch on the sidelines, eating hot dogs and letting popsicles stain their shirts. The crack of wooden bats as the sun sets beyond centerfield. Old school Americana.

🎥 Go deeper:

3. ⚾️ The village of Cooperstown

Photo: Jim McIsaac/Getty Images

The National Baseball Hall of Fame was opened in Cooperstown, New York in 1939, with an inaugural class of Babe Ruth, Ty Cobb, Honus Wagner, Christy Mathewson and Walter Johnson that will never be topped.

  • Since then, the village of 1,762 people has hosted hundreds of thousands of baseball-loving tourists every year, highlighted by the annual Hall of Fame induction ceremony in late July.
  • Sadly, this year's ceremony has been canceled due to the coronavirus, meaning Derek Jeter, Larry Walker and the rest of this year's class will have to wait another year for their big day.

Meanwhile, down the road: Cooperstown Dreams Park, an 80-acre complex with 23 youth fields that hosts nearly 17,000 players every summer, is just one of the many businesses in the area hurt by COVID-related cancellations.

  • Decades ago, when the park's founder Lou Presutti visited the Hall of Fame with his family, his father told him that "every kid in America should have the chance to play baseball at Cooperstown." He took those words to heart, and in 1996 his own personal field of dreams was opened for business.
  • Alumni of the park's summer league include Mike Trout, Bryce Harper and countless other major leaguers, each of whom paid $850 for their week of Cooperstown baseball (so you can imagine how much this summer's cancellation is costing the park).

4. 🔙 Past stoppages/near-stoppages

WWI posters. Photos: Getty Images. Illustration: Eniola Odetunde/Axios

WWI: The Great War was deep into its fourth year when the 1918 season began — and a deadly virus was lurking just out of sight. The "Work or Fight" order stipulated that all draft-eligible men in non-essential jobs either begin working for the war effort or prepare to be drafted, but MLB was granted a reprieve to play until Labor Day, resulting in a shortened, but saved, season.

Ted Williams saluting officer
Photo: Bettmann/Getty Images

WWII: When the U.S. entered the fray in late 1941, MLB commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis sought President Roosevelt's counsel. FDR's famous response to Landis, now known as the Green Light Letter, urged him to push the season forward as planned: "I honestly feel that it would be best for the country to keep baseball going."

  • Pictured above: Fresh off his fourth season, including two straight top-two MVP finishes, 23-year-old Ted Williams entered active duty as a Marine pilot before the 1943 season, missing three full seasons serving his country.
Young fan at baseball game
Photo: Robert Gauthier/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images

Sept. 11, 2001: After the 9/11 attacks, commissioner Bud Selig immediately postponed all games that Tuesday evening, and ultimately postponed everything through the end of the week. Play resumed on Monday, but it was Friday the 21st that everyone remembers.

  • 🎥 Highlight: The Mets hosted the Braves in New York's first game back, and Mike Piazza lifted his team, and his city, with an iconic game-winning HR in the 8th. Chills.

And here we are now ... Maybe baseball will be back this summer, maybe not. But it will return — it always has.

5. 🚇 Baseball haiku

The Exorcist Train GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Reader Stephen S. Power (Maplewood, N.J.) writes:

"As someone who watched more than 120 Yankee games last year, I'm struggling. To pass the time, inspired by the book 'Baseball Haiku,' I've been writing a haiku myself for each lost game."

Here's one:

only the Yankees

could make the subway

smell like spring

6. ❤️ Breaking the curse

Grave covered in Red Sox gear
Courtesy: Raymond Sinibaldi

Boston native Paul Smith recalls the night the Red Sox broke the Curse of the Bambino, and the moment he shared with his father, a lifelong fan who had passed away three years earlier. From HBO's "Sports in America" documentary:

"I remember the day. It was Oct. 27, 2004. I called my sons, we congratulated each other, and I just had this feeling. I said, 'I'm going to visit your grandfather.'
"I drove across town to the cemetery, figured it would be locked up, so I parked my car on the street and climbed over the stone wall.
"It's the middle of the night, and I'm walking across the cemetery, and all of a sudden, a police cruiser pulls out of the bushes practically and drives up to me.
"I'm mortified. I'm a grown man, I'm doing this silly thing. Chagrined, I say, 'I'm sorry, officer, I know I'm not supposed to be here, but this is kind of an important night. I just wanted to share a moment with my dad.'
"And he said to me, 'Are you kidding me pal? Take a look around.'
"My eyes were just getting adjusted to the darkness. Sure enough, people were walking everywhere in the cemetery. There were cars driving back and forth, up and down the lanes with their lights out.
"The officer said, 'I'm just here to make sure there's not a traffic jam. Everybody's here to share their moments with their father, their grandmother, their brother. The Red Sox won. We won it all.'"

🎥 It's better in video form ... You will cry.

7. 🎬 Seven movie scenes

Animated GIF - Find & Share on GIPHY

Whether through tear-jerking sentiment, humor or the full range of emotions that fill the space between, baseball movies tend to over-index on moments that just make you smile. Here are seven of our favorites:

8. 🏆 The World Series circuit

Three World Series. All canceled.

2019 llws champions
2019 Little League World Series champions from Eastbank Little League in River Ridge, Louisiana. Photo: Rob Carr/Getty Images

SOUTH WILLIAMSPORT, Pa. — Every August since 1947, this tiny town (population ~6,500) has hosted the Little League World Series. That streak ends this summer.

  • Sidenote: Is there anything more visceral and organic than the celebratory dogpile? Above, little leaguers tackle each other in joy, and below, college athletes do the same. What a feeling.
2019 cws champions
2019 College World Series champions, the Vanderbilt Commodores. Photo: Peter Aiken/Getty Images

OMAHA, Neb. The College World Series also began in 1947, though it didn't find its way to Omaha until 1950. (Fun fact: Yale was the runner-up in both 1947 and 1948, led by infielder and team captain George H. W. Bush.)

  • Winningest team: USC (12 titles) has twice as many championships as any other school, though they've won just once since 1978, and none this century.
2019 wcws championship game
2019 Women's College World Series Championship at ASA Hall of Fame Stadium in Oklahoma City. Photo: Tim Nwachukwu/NCAA Photos via Getty Images

OKLAHOMA CITY — From 1969 to 1989, the host city for the Women's College World Series moved all over the country. But since 1990 (save 1996, when Columbus, Georgia hosted to prove it could host Olympic softball), it has been at Oklahoma City's ASA Hall of Fame Stadium.

  • Winningest team: UCLA has won 13* titles, including last year's walk-off victory. (*Technically 12, with its 1995 title vacated due to a scholarship infraction.)

9. ⭐️ Countdown: MLB all-time rosters

Player data from Baseball Reference; Graphic: Andrew Witherspoon/Axios

Over the next 30 editions of Axios Sports, we'll be counting down the all-time rosters for all 30 MLB teams, starting with the weakest starting lineup and ending with the strongest. Want to debate our picks? Email [email protected]. Let's begin...

30. Tampa Bay Rays

They're tied for the youngest franchise in MLB, so it's hard to blame Tampa Bay for coming in dead last. It's also part of their charm, as they've become known for putting together teams who are much greater than the sum of their parts.

  • Year established: 1998
  • All-time record: 1,686-1,876 (.473)
  • World Series Championships: 0
  • Hall of Famers (on this roster): 0

Starting lineup:

  1. OF Carl Crawford (35.6 bWAR with team)
  2. 2B Ben Zobrist (35.3)
  3. 3B Evan Longoria (51.8)
  4. DH Fred McGriff (9)
  5. 1B Carlos Peña (18.1)
  6. OF Melvin Upton Jr. (15.6)
  7. OF Kevin Kiermaier (25.7)
  8. SS Julio Lugo (13.5)
  9. C Toby Hall (5.7)

On the mound: SP David Price (21.1)


  • Infield: 2B Logan Forsythe (9.4), 3B Aubrey Huff (11.9), SS Jason Bartlett (10.4), C Dioner Navarro (1.9)
  • Outfield: Desmond Jennings (13.5), Matthew Joyce (10.3), Rocco Baldelli (9.6)
  • Utility: Steven Souza (6.3), Randy Winn (7.3)
  • Rotation: James Shields (20), Scott Kazmir (16.5), Chris Archer (11.9), Blake Snell (10.3)
  • Bullpen: Roberto Hernández (4.9), Fernando Rodney (4.2), Alex Colomé (4.1)

Additional notes:

  • James Shields: Easy to forget now, but he was one of the premier pitchers in the league no so long ago. His 11 complete games in 2011 are the most since Randy Johnson had 12 in 1999.
  • Catchers: They're generally the weakest part of any lineup, but 7.6 combined WAR is particularly egregious. Wilson Ramos played just 142 games for them and his 25 HR is fourth all-time among Rays catchers.
  • Carl Crawford: What happened here?!? Nine years as a stud in Tampa (35.6 WAR) earned him a massive seven-year contract worth $142 million with the Red Sox in 2011, but he compiled just 3.6 additional WAR over the next six seasons before being released and then retiring.

Huge thanks to Tom Stone, whose book 'Now Taking the Field: Baseball's All-Time Dream Teams for All 30 Franchises,' provided the inspiration for these rosters.

10. 🔗 Good links

Photos courtesy of Topps. Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

Talk tomorrow,

Kendall "Never taking baseball for granted again" Baker