H.R. McMaster in a meeting between President Trump and Saudi Arabia's Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman on March 20, 2018. Photo: Mandel Mgan/AFP/Getty Images
What they're saying: "[L]ike the last book, 'Siege' is ultimately crippled by three flaws," Ryan Lizza writes in his WashPost review. "Wolff’s overreliance on a single character [Bannon], and one who is now more distant from the action; factual errors that mar the author's credibility; and sourcing that is so opaque it renders the scoops highly suspicious and unreliable."