Dec 4, 2023 - News

Recordings reveal Mormon church response to sex abuse case

Illustration: Brendan Lynch/Axios

In audio recordings linked to an Idaho child sex abuse case, the risk management director for the Church of Jesus of Latter-day Saints offered the alleged victim a $300,000 confidentiality agreement, the Associated Press reported late Sunday.

  • The recordings give an "unprecedented record of the steps the church normally takes behind closed doors to keep allegations of child sex abuse secret," the report states.

Details: In 2016, police in Mountain Home, Idaho, arrested a dentist and former Mormon church bishop — the title for lay clergy — after the man's adult daughter reported he had sexually abused her during her childhood.

  • The dentist's relatives told police they had previously taken him to confess to his church bishop, and he was excommunicated.
  • Shortly after the arrest, another woman accused the dentist of drugging and assaulting her.
  • But prosecutors dropped the daughter's case in mid-2017 and struck a plea deal in the drug case that eliminated sex crime charges. The man remains a practicing dentist.

What happened: The dentist's daughter and wife said prosecutors told them they'd have a case if the bishop would report the dentist's confession.

  • But the church discouraged the bishop from testifying, citing an Idaho law that exempts clergy from reporting crimes disclosed during religious confession.

Of note: The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has joined other religious groups in supporting "clergy-penitent privilege," even though its own bishops have said such laws prevent them from reporting crimes.

  • The dentist's bishop told the AP: "If I say anything, [the dentist] can sue me for millions of dollars."
  • Powerful Mormon lawmakers and Catholic lobbying have stymied efforts to close the reporting loophole in Utah and Arizona, the AP previously reported.

The latest: An Arizona judge last month cited the privilege when he dismissed a high-profile lawsuit accusing the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints of failing to report a father who confessed to years of child abuse.

The intrigue: In a recording posted by the AP, the church's risk management director can be heard offering the Idaho dentist's family $300,000 to not sue the church or disclose the payment.

  • That recording was made by a fellow church member who attended the meetings to support the alleged victim and did not agree to confidentiality, the AP reports.

The other side: The church on Monday took the unusual step of responding directly to the AP on X, formerly Twitter.

  • "Only the perpetrator could release the bishop from his obligation under the clergy penitent privilege and he refused to do so," the statement reads in part.
  • In its statement to the AP, the church said, "The abuse of a child or any other individual is inexcusable," and that the dentist, following his excommunication, "has not been readmitted to church membership."

Get more local stories in your inbox with Axios Salt Lake City.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more

More Salt Lake City stories

No stories could be found

Salt Lake Citypostcard

Get a free daily digest of the most important news in your backyard with Axios Salt Lake City.


Support local journalism by becoming a member.

Learn more