Illustration: Aïda Amer/Axios
"Try to remember how you felt in September 2008, right when you learned Lehman collapsed. Were you more scared then, or are you more scared now?"
The intrigue: That's a question I've been asking investors and other sources since late February. When I began, the responses were pretty evenly split.
- This week, all but two people said they are more scared now — and that majority includes several big names who were previously siding with 2008.
The argument in favor of 2008 being scarier is that no one knew if the pit had a bottom, or if we'd just spiral endlessly — vacuuming up Main Street after Wall Street.
- Our present slide, while horrific, will eventually end — if not because of social distancing, then because scientists discover treatments and/or vaccines.
The argument for 2020 is that Main Street and much of Corporate America are being eviscerated simultaneously.
- Wall Street may be relatively immune so far, outside of plunging equity prices and M&A fee interruptions, but Wall Street is just a lubricant for the American economy — it's not the pistons. And if we begin to see a large wave of corporate defaults, both Wall Street and private equity will feel a suffocating squeeze of their own.
- Add to this the fear of sickness and death, particularly for older Americans, neither of which we experienced in 2008.
The bottom line: While we are always captive to the present, it is objectively reasonable to call this the most fraught moment of our collective lives. Decisions that get made over the next several days and weeks, including the White House's $1 trillion stimulus proposal that many think is too small, will be consequential for most everything ever again covered in this newsletter, or in media like it.