Aug 15, 2018

India's unlikely, enduring democracy

Prime Minister Shri Jawaharial Nehru and Shrimati Vijayalakshmi, the former Ambassador to the U.S.A., with Eleanor Roosevelt in 1952. Photo: Bettmann via Getty

Just five years after India gained independence — 71 years ago today — voters across the newly-born nation cast ballots in its first ever election. Some 176 million citizens, 85% of whom could neither read nor write, were eligible to participate in the vote.

Flash forward: Since then, India’s democracy has withstood the test of time. It’s in many ways an unlikely story. The sprawling nation of more 1.3 billion people is riven by divisions of language, class, and religion. The constitution recognizes 22 separate major languages that are spoken by at least one million people. A majority Hindu nation, India also boasts the world’s second largest Muslim population. The vestiges of the hierarchical caste system continue to limit people’s educational, career, and life prospects.

Despite these hurdles, the country has experienced seven decades of almost uninterrupted democratic rule.

  • Today, around 5% of Indians live in extreme poverty, down from a high of 60% just four decades ago. The administration of current Prime Minister Narendra Modi has made important strides in expanding access to electricity, healthcare, and sanitation.

There is plenty of work left to do.

  • The share of income accruing to the top 1%, a broad measure of inequality, is the highest since tax collection began in 1922.
  • Many find Modi’s push to move India away from its secular roots toward a new brand of democracy based around identification with its Hindu cultural and religious history worrisome.
  • The government’s recent threat to strip 4 million people, many of whom are migrants from the predominantly Muslim Bangladesh, of their citizenship demonstrates the danger.

Despite these challenges, at a moment when democracy is increasingly in question and under threat around the world, India’s largely successful effort over the past seven decades to reconcile the competing identities and passions of over 15% of the world’s population is a staggering accomplishment.

Sign up for Signal, a twice-weekly newsletter from GZERO Media, a Eurasia Group company.

Go deeper

Trump acknowledges lists of disloyal government officials to oust

Photo: Mandel Ngan/AFP via Getty Images

President Trump on Monday acknowledged the existence of assembled lists of government officials that his administration plans to oust and replace with trusted pro-Trump people, which were first reported by Axios' Jonathan Swan.

What he's saying: “I don’t think it's a big problem. I don’t think it's very many people,” Trump said during a press conference in India, adding he wants “people who are good for the country, loyal to the country.”

Coronavirus only part of the story behind the Dow’s drop

Photo: Andrew Burton/Getty Images

As someone has certainly told you by now, the Dow fell by more than 1,000 points yesterday, its worst day in more than two years, erasing all of 2020's gains. Most news headlines assert that the stock market's momentum was finally broken by "coronavirus fears," but that's not the full story.

What's happening: The novel coronavirus has been infecting and killing scores of people for close to a month and, depending on the day, the market has sold off or risen to record highs.

Bernie's historic Jewish fight

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

Sen. Bernie Sanders would be the first Jewish presidential nominee of a major American political party — but that history-making possibility is being overshadowed by his conflicts with America's Jewish leaders and Israel's leadership.

The big picture: That's partly because we're all focusing on the implications of Democrats nominating a self-described democratic socialist. It's also because a candidate's religion no longer seems to matter as much to voters or the media, making the potential milestone of a Jewish nominee more of a non-event.