Nov 2, 2017

Chance plays a role in how languages change

Illustration: Rebecca Zisser / Axios

Since Darwin's day, the principles of evolution have been used to try to explain how and why language changes. In a new study, researchers look at changes within the English language over short periods of time and find random chance plays a larger role than previously thought in quickly altering aspects of language.

What's new: Techniques used by biologists to study genetic changes have been honed, and linguists can now use them to analyze the large amounts of digitized texts. Understanding what causes individual words, sounds and syntax to change within a single language could provide clues about how new languages arise. And, advances in linguistic understanding have led to better speech recognition, predictive text, artificial intelligence and related algorithms.

Bottom line: We are beginning to get a detailed picture of the history of language, much like we have for the history of species.

"This is a really interesting piece of work that nicely combines large-scale databases with quantitative modeling. These approaches are becoming more common in linguistics, helping to revitalize the field," says Simon Greenhill from the Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History, who was not involved in the research but recently analyzed 81 Austronesian languages (from islands in Southeast Asia and the Pacific) and found their grammar changed faster than their lexicon.

How evolution works: Selection is when one form of a word is preferred over another — because it sounds better, is popular or more effective, or is easier to say or remember — and therefore perpetuated, whereas drift or neutral evolution is when a version of a word is randomly copied. It just sort of happens.

What they did: Physicist-turned-biologist Mitchell Newberry and linguist Christopher Ahern along with their colleagues at the University of Pennsylvania ran their statistical models, which borrow from techniques in population genetics, on databases of digitized texts containing more than 400 million words and spanning the 12th to 21st centuries. They tested the models on three known grammatical changes in the English language:

  1. The use of -ed to create past-tense verbs. They found drift accounted for changes in rare verbs that make them more prone to being replaced. And, the preferred form of just six of the 36 verbs they studied arose via selection. Some were irregular, which linguists have hypothesized may be because those forms pleasingly rhyme with other words being used frequently at the time. In the study, the rise of the irregular verb quit was found to coincide with more use of the words hit, split and slit, supporting the hypothesis.
  2. The rise of do as a verb. Random drift seems to have initially brought do into questions beginning in the 1500s and then natural selection took over as do made its way into other contexts like when Say not that! became Don't say that! for "reasons of grammatical consistency or cognitive ease," they wrote.
  3. How negative sentences were formed. In Middle English, the phrase was I not say, then it changed to I not say not, then by Shakespeare's time it was, I say not and, finally, I don't say. This cycle of moving no around to wherever it gives us the most emphasis was known to happen across many languages due to natural selection and the test basically acted as the control for their model.
"One of the crucial things we've added is that at certain time scales — year by year counts as opposed to century by century — the picture is really different. If you look at the data in a fine grain way, you will discover new things," says Ahern.

Yes, but: Some linguists contacted by Axios were skeptical the study's findings were novel and said historical data is incomplete. "The amount of material we have varies a lot from century to century, and that affects the conclusions that can be drawn from the dataset," says Claire Bowern, a linguist at Yale University who was not involved in the study. She also points out that linguists have looked at the role of random drift in language change before.

The response: Ahern says that among linguists, "the level of detail at which these changes are 'well known' is a little bit overstated." And, he says the point is he and his colleagues came up with a way to test long-standing hypotheses for the first time. "We're building in language the intellectual infrastructure that we built in genetics in the 60s," Newberry says.

What's next: Determining whether the patterns occur in other languages and extending and nuancing the models by incorporating other work in linguistics, Greenhill says.

Go deeper

George Floyd updates

Protesters gather north of Lafayette Square near the White House during a demonstration against racism and police brutality, in Washington, D.C. on Saturday evening. Photo: Jose Luis Magana/AFP via Getty Images

Tens of thousands of demonstrators have been rallying in cities across the U.S. and around the world to protest the killing of George Floyd. Huge crowds assembled in Washington, D.C., Philadelphia and Chicago for full-day events on Saturday.

Why it matters: Twelve days of nationwide protest in the U.S. has built pressure for states to make changes on what kind of force law enforcement can use on civilians and prompted officials to review police conduct. A memorial service was held for Floyd in Raeford, North Carolina, near where he was born. Gov. Roy Cooper ordered all flags to fly at half-staff to honor him until sunset.

Updated 3 hours ago - Politics & Policy

Coronavirus dashboard

Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios

  1. Global: Total confirmed cases as of 11:30 p.m. ET: 6,889,889 — Total deaths: 399,642 — Total recoveries — 3,085,326Map.
  2. U.S.: Total confirmed cases as of 11:30 p.m. ET: 1,920,061 — Total deaths: 109,802 — Total recoveries: 500,849 — Total tested: 19,778,873Map.
  3. Public health: Why the pandemic is hitting minorities harder — Coronavirus curve rises in FloridaHow racism threatens the response to the pandemic Some people are drinking and inhaling cleaning products in attempt to fight the virus.
  4. Tech: The pandemic is accelerating next-generation disease diagnostics — Robotics looks to copy software-as-a-service model.
  5. Business: Budgets busted by coronavirus make it harder for cities to address inequality Sports, film production in California to resume June 12 after 3-month hiatus.
  6. Education: Students and teachers flunked remote learning.
Updated 7 hours ago - World

In photos: People around the world rally against racism

Despite a ban on large gatherings implemented in response to the coronavirus pandemic, protesters rally against racism in front of the American Embassy in Paris on June 6. Photo: Julien Mattia/Anadolu Agency via Getty Images

Tens of thousands of people have continued to rally in cities across the world against racism and show their support this week for U.S. demonstrators protesting the death in police custody of George Floyd.

Why it matters: The tense situation in the U.S. has brought the discussion of racism and discrimination onto the global stage at a time when most of the world is consumed by the novel coronavirus.