Dec 12, 2019

The Cost of Health

Theresa Carnegie of Mintz shares her perspective at the Axios roundtable. Photo: Hector Emanuel for Axios

This Tuesday, Axios' health care business reporter Bob Herman and Co-founder Mike Allen hosted an Expert Voices Live discussion on drug pricing and demystifying the pharmaceutical supply chain.

A broken system

While the discussion proved to be a lively debate, there was one area of agreement among attendees — the current health care system and its approach to drug pricing and coverage — is broken.

Sean Dickson and Marcie McClintic Coates look on as Robert DuBois speaks. Photo: Hector Emanuel for Axios
  • Robert DuBois, Chief Science Officer and Executive Vice President and the National Pharmaceutical Council, shared his opinion on high out of pocket costs: "Insurance is supposed to be the healthy subsidizing the sick, but with high out of pocket for drugs, it's the sick subsidizing the healthy."
  • Sean Dickson, Director of Health Policy at West Health, on the system: "The complexity of the system that we built well over a decade ago is contributing to the difficulty of reforming it."
Possible fixes

Herman asked the group if they saw relatively easy fixes to the current health care bills that would allow for widespread support.

  • Jennifer Bryant, Executive Vice President of Policy and Research at PhRMA, highlighted a topic of agreement among the table, "There are distorted incentives that are leading to less uptake of biosimilars and generics than we might otherwise see. One of the reasons is the incentive to put higher list-price products on formulary, and that penalizes patients the most."
  • Marcie McClintic Coates, Head of Global Policy at Mylan, stressed the importance of fixing the formulary tiers, "The formulary tiers still look like 2003, we've not kept a formulary tier for any speciality generics or biosimilars, we have a one-size-fits-all bucket."
  • Jack Hoadley, Researcher at Georgetown's Health Policy Institute, suggested solutions to encourage biosimilar penetration, "Some of it is just acceptance and education among the public and providers that biosimilars are a substitute, the other is figuring out — at several levels, including at the FDA — how to get biosimilars into the market."
Bob Herman and John Rother connect after the event. Photo: Hector Emanuel for Axios
More time, please

As the conversation came to a close, Bob Herman listed the topics he had hoped to cover with the group — the Institute for Clinical and Economic Review's reports, rebates, and an alternative system for drug pricing — if they had more time. The discussion concluded with the following key insights:

  • Matt Kazan, Principal at Avalere, spoke about his time on the hill and the three things needed to get bills like H.R.3 get passed, "Members of Congress can explain the provision at home, it's bipartisan, and the Congressional Budget Office says it saves money."
Michael Budros of Healthsperien at the Axios roundtable. Photo: Hector Emanuel for Axios
  • Michael Budros, Policy Director at Healthsperien, mentioned one topic left out of the conversation, "We haven't talked about how drugs and prices connect to the value to patients...It's something to think about in future iterations of price and cost reform."

Thank you, Mylan for sponsoring this event.

Go deeper

Health Care Vitals: Washington, D.C.

Dr. Scott Gottlieb answers a question from Mike Allen. Photo: Lawrence Jackson for Axios

This Wednesday morning, Axios Co-founder Mike Allen hosted a series of one-on-one conversations on the future of comprehensive health care across urban and rural America. Topics covered included how to get affordable and accessible care, as well as news of the day items like the rise in youth addiction to nicotine.

Go deeperArrowDec 13, 2019

The health care debate we ought to be having

Photo Illustration: Sarah Grillo/Axios. Photos: Scott Eisen/Getty Images and Erik McGregor/LightRocket via Getty Images

Americans worry a lot about how to get and pay for good health care, but the 2020 presidential candidates are barely talking about what's at the root of these problems: Almost every incentive in the U.S. health care system is broken.

Why it matters: President Trump and most of the Democratic field are minimizing the hard conversations with voters about why health care eats up so much of each paycheck and what it would really take to change things.

The health care industry's happy holidays

Illustration: Eniola Odetunde/Axios

The year-end spending bill in Congress epitomizes the power of health care interests.

The big picture: There are lots of goodies for the industry, while patients will get the worst kind of holiday surprise — more medical bills.

Go deeperArrowDec 20, 2019